A few weeks ago a white umpire at a Gadsden high school baseball game demanded that the players stop speaking Spanish. If you don't have any context or history with El Paso area baseball - this sounds terrible. If you do have context and history playing baseball in El Paso - this was actually a pretty normal deal. The EP Times has done the health of the local sport no good and in the process embarrassed themselves.
The op-ed the Times ran can by read HERE. They note that the umpire quit after the story blew up into something it should have never been. It is likely that he spoke with a lawyer, and if you know lawyers, you know that he was advised to quit. A lawyer's first response to your question; I'm being sued, what should I do? Is always - stop doing whatever you were doing to get sued.
The El Paso Times thinks the guy should not have quit, but instead stuck around for an official public spanking that would be the trigger for no less than about three lawsuits - civil rights against the umpire, civil rights against the district that provided the umpire and another flat civil lawsuit against the umpire.
The Times wrote: "We would have preferred a strong ruling from the activities association that would have set the ground rules for all official."
We are a litigious society and lawyers look for "official" admission of wrong doing as the smoking gun in civil cases. The El Paso Times is either too dumb to realize this, or happy to have millions of dollars wasted on what was actually the right call by the umpire - which I'm going to get to.
You can't run a story calling for a man's head and then get upset when he doesn't stick around for your unfair punishment. Umpires, as usual, in El Paso are in short supply. It hurts high school baseball more than it hurts this umpire to walk away. Had the paper been about fairness, they would have run an op-ed today saying "we screwed up by making a mountain out of a molehill."
Here's why what the umpire did was in fact a molehill.
I grew up playing baseball in El Paso. I was on travel teams, high school teams and had a short stint with the Tejanos before heading off to Texas Tech to try my luck drinking beer in exchange for course credits. I have played literally hundreds of baseball games in the area. I know how El Paso baseball differs from baseball in the rest of the state. It's not just the style of play and the fans, it's the language most El Paso ballplayers can fall back on to communicate clearly and openly without the other team knowing what they are saying. That advantage has its upside and its downside.
Not only have I heard umpires ask a coach to tell his players to speak English, I have had them ban either team from speaking at all in any language. When high school boys start jawing back and forth, fights can break out and shutting everyone up is the best option other than stopping the game.
When an umpire that doesn't speak Spanish is in a situation where players are using the language to go around him and his authority, he has to do something about it. I can tell you that I heard Spanish speaking players dressing down white umpires all the time with a smile on their face. They think it's funny because the umpire has no idea what they are saying... in most cases, one umpire knew Spanish and ejected the kid calling him names in Spanish and explained to the principal and his parents on the spot what the kid was saying about his sexual orientation. The worst part was that the coaches never got on their players for saying nasty things to white umpires in Spanish. In fact, one famous local coach would lament how some players could smile like an angel while calling an umpire every dirty name in the Spanish book. The umpire would have no idea, but the crowd and other players knew.
The umpire needs to know what's being said when the teams are communicating with him or the other team. If Team A is inviting Team B out for a fight - he needs to know that before it happens. The home plate ump may not be hearing what's going on. The umpires are there not only to call balls and strikes, but to maintain order. When players switch to a language they knothe umpire doesn't speak to incite a fight, or call him names, that umpire must do something about it.
Now, it's not like this umpire started out the game saying "English only or you can go back to Mexico." Nope, something triggered it and from what I understand it was one or both of the situations I have described above. The coach was in on it and decided to make a federal case of it because he's a whiny little baby looking to cash in. Anybody who has played baseball in El Paso has had an umpire make requests like this. In our modern victim society this was turned into something it wasn't - racism. Again, this guy didn't make a statement about the overall use of Spanish in everyday life, he simply needed them to stop communicating to each other in a language he didn't understand because he thought they were using it to be rude. We all know what cute little games teenagers play and this was one of those games.
Being short an umpire sucks. I play in an adult baseball league here in DC and not having umpires for a game ruins the experience. In high school it could make a game not count. Now, because a coach is siding with badly behaving players the area is minus one good umpire. Let's hope Gadsden gets shorted an umpire before the season is out.
And remember - umpiring high school baseball is short pay for dealing with a bunch asshole kids.
Recent Comments